Intelligent Design

[xenophanean]

Ok, here's one which no-one's been able to adequately explain to me:

A person/thing wakes up in a universe. He/she/it doesn't understand, or know the universe, but does know three things (for absolutely certain,  really knows, they're True, (rules of the universe, what one might call 'divine knowledge')):

1) That this is the only universe
2) That he/she/it is the only possible conscious being
3) That this is the only possible universe that he/she/it could have existed in.

Is said individual right to think that there is some sort of creator/ceative urge who wanted/required him/her/it in it?

I'm told that the answer is No. I'm prepared to accept that he/she/it just doesn't know, not enough info.

I'd really like to be convinced of Yes or No. But I'd also like get an explanation of what "not enough info" means in this case too.

Comments

[andrewducker]

Yup - that's one of the things that intermittently annoys me about creationists. They tend to go "People are complex. Therefore there is a creator. And he hates gay people." leaving me thinking that possibly there's a hole or two in their logic process.

[(Anonymous)]

The actual point of the argument is one against atheism. We won't ever know whether the three points above are actually true. Despite this it seems like those three statements are a reasonable possibility for what the true status of the universe could be.

As such, there could be reason to think there is some sort of guiding force behind the universe, albeit, given the number of unknowns involved, we have no idea how to assess the likelihood. Thus, atheism requires a certain amount of faith that this situation (or a similar one) isn't the case, without any evidence either way. So to be completely and firmly atheist is very slightly irrational.

[andrewducker]

My basic argument against atheism is that "lack of proof" does not equal "proof of lack". Just because we've never seen God does not mean that there absolutely definitely isn't one.

It does make certain things a lot less likely, of course. And I find pretty much all of the conceptions I've run into pretty darn silly. But that doesn't mean it's impossible.